Search blog.co.uk

What Are We Thinking?

by a_poke_in_the_mind @ 2007-04-14 - 12:56:35

I recently saw a reporter on TV who spent the last few years in Iraq. He said he’d had life-changing experiences there and when pressed to tell of one, he recounted an episode about the kidnapping of a young girl.
It seems that the daughter of a fairly rich Iraqi man was kidnapped and held for ransom -- a rather common occurrence these days I understand. When the kidnappers called to talk about the ransom, the father demanded to talk to his daughter. She came on the line sobbing and crying, quite terrified, hardly able to speak. Her father only wanted to know from her whether she had been raped. She finally sobbed yes.
He told her to give the phone back to one of her captors and when that despot came on the line the father told him to keep his daughter, he didn’t want her back. And so they killed the daughter.
Here was a young girl sentenced to death by her father -- who apparently could have saved her quite easily -- because she’d been raped and was no longer a virgin. And we are sending our children over to Iraq to fight and die for the rights of her father – this homicidal maniac. What are we thinking?
Near the end of the Viet Nam war it is said that the tipping point for public opinion came when on the six o’clock news we all clearly saw that Viet Namese officer shoot in the head a young soldier who was handcuffed and kneeling.
Isn’t the story of this child’s death even more horrible? She was no enemy combatant; just a young innocent caught in the middle. Can’t we clearly see her handcuffed and kneeling? Can’t we clearly see that despicable abductor putting a gun to her young head and pulling the trigger? And can’t we clearly see her -- who had most certainly loved her equally despicable father and always tried to live up to his maniacal code, but sadly and helplessly got caught in-between -- see her fall, dead before she hit the dirt floor?
PEOPLE, WE ARE SENDING OUR CHILDREN TO FIGHT AND DIE FOR THE RIGHTS OF MEN SO UTTERLY MORALLY TWISTED THAT THEY VALUE THEIR DAUGHTERS’ VIRGINITY HIGHER THAN THEIR DAUGHTERS’ LIVES!! PLEASE TELL ME, WHAT ARE WE THINKING?!!!!!
Clearly there is someone in this gut-wrenching story worthy of us fighting for, but she’s dead. She may have a younger sister who is still alive, but sadly we can’t save her sister either. We should know by now that we cannot change the beliefs and codes, the traditions, values and laws of billions of people by force. What are we thinking?
Over time and by example, I believe that we are likely to save her sister’s daughter’s daughter’s daughter -- however many generations into the future -- but our futile attempts to force change only serve to strengthen the resolve and increase the numbers of opponents of change, thus pushing those changes farther into the distant future.


 
 

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

E [Visitor]

04/18/07 @ 21:11

Greg, The fate of the girl is very sad. If only the world could be better for all . . . . EMB

Jim Millsap [Visitor]

04/22/07 @ 17:36

Your writing is good and holds the reader well. The story, while tragic and unthinkable in our society, is simply a fact of life in their society.

Personally, I am equally appalled by the way these terrorists display the beheading of journalists, military personel and contractors, and other Americans on the internet for the world to see. These incidents, combined with the attack of 9/11, should give anyone with an ounce of understanding the ability to comprehend the reasons that we had to take the fight to the middle east. These people are intent on killing Americans for no other reason than the fact that they are Americans. They are barbaric, ruthless, and evil. They must be dealt with over there! I doubt that you or any of your readers really want to confront them in your own back yard.

If our fathers and grandfathers had been so weak on defense, we all (at least those with blonde hair and blue eyes) would be speaking German today! Of Course, the others would be burried in mass graves in concentration camps that just might still be active.

I would love to see the day when the nations could have their differences and still be civil to all other nations but that day will never come as long as there are lunatics running around bombing and killing people because they don't accept the teachings of their prophet. I think it's pretty obvious who the aggressor is in this war and they need to be eliminated wherever they are found.

Jim M

Jim

Greg Schindler [Visitor]

04/23/07 @ 15:13

I think we just have to agree to disagree, Jim, but since you mentioned those barbaric beheadings I thought I'd point out something. No government, elected or otherwise, is responsible for those beheadings, but if one was, we'd hold it accountable and if it was an elected regime, we might hold those who voted it in accountable as well. Now, death by torture is more barbaric than beheading. I doubt you'd disagree in that. I think you'd prefer a mercifully quick beheading to a long tortured death. Do you see where I'm going? There's now a country in the world claiming to be civilized, while it tortures prisoners -- some to death. We don't know how many, do we? I'm more angry that my country's doing something so barbaric in my name, than I am about a small handful of men who's country was invaded and occupied do in what they consider to be self defense. "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone." When we who are torturing prisoners to death accuse beheaders of barbarism, it sounds like the pot calling the kettle black to me. Greg

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.